Does long-term follow-up have a role for node negative squamous carcinoma of the vulva? The Gateshead experience

A retrospective review was performed of 138 cases of squamous vulval cancer referred to Gateshead between 1986 and 1997, with a median follow-up of 48 months. Eighteen recurrences were detected, 11 within one year of surgery. All nine patients with groin/distant recurrence (including 4 presenting initially with local recurrence only) died of vulval cancer. Vulval pain, bleeding or other symptoms heralded all recurrences. Routine review was ineffective in detecting recurrence. Eight cases were detected by general practitioners, three by specialists, and one was self-diagnosed. Six of these had had clinical review less than two months previously. Follow-up does not appear to offer early detection or survival advantages. Patient education, with symptom-triggered rapid clinic access, may be more effective. Prospective research is indicated to assess both the effectiveness and psychological implications of routine follow-up and alternative strategies.

Vulval cancer; Negative lymph nodes; Recurrence; Follow-up

[1] Allsop J. R., Preston J., Crocker S.: "ls there any value in the long term follow up of women treated for endometrial cancer?". Br. J. Obstet. Gynaecol., 1997, 104, 119.

[2] Owen P., Duncan I. D.: "Is there any value in the long term follow up of women treated for endometrial cancer?". Br. J. Obstet. Gynaecol., 1996, 103, 710.

[3] Salvesen H. B., Akslen L. A., Iverson T.: "Recurrence of endometrial carcinoma and the value of routine follow up" Br. J. Obstet. Gynaecol., 1997, 104, 1302.

[4] Ansink A.,L ope、 A. Db,N aik R.,M onaghan J.M.: "Recurrent Stage 1B cervical carcinoma: evaluation of the effectiveness of routine follow up surveillance". Br. J. Obstet. Gynaecol., 1996, 103, 1156.

[5] Eastwood A., Melville A., Kleijen J.: "Guidance on Commissioning Cancer Services. Improving Outcomes in Gynaecological Cancer. The Research Evidence". NHS Centre of Reviews and Dissemination, University of York for the NHS Executive, 1999.

[6] Grimshaw R. N., Murdoch J.B., Monaghan J. M.: "Radical vulvectomy and b仆ateral inguinal-femoral lymphadenectomy through separate incisions ~ experience with 100 cases". Int. J. Gynecol. Cancer, 1993, 3, 18.

[7] Kerr-Wilson R. H;, McCrum A.: "Follow-up of patients with gynaecological cancer". Aust. N. Z. J. Obstet. Gynaecol., 1995, 35, 298.

[8] Auchincloss S. S.: "After treatment. Psychosocial issues in gynecologic cancer survivorship". Cancer, 1995, 76 (10 Suppl.), 2117.

[9] Bradley E. J., Pitts M. K., Redman C. W. E., Calvert E.: "The experience of long term hospital follow-up for women who have suffered early stage gynaecological cancer: a qualitative interview study". Int. J. Gynecol. Cancer, 1999, 9, 491.

[10] Kiebert G. M., Welvaart K., Kievit J.: "Psychological effects of routine follow up on cancer patients after surgery". Eur. J. Surg., 1993,159, 601.