Improved early detection of cervical intraepithelial lesions by combination of conventional Pap smear and speculoscopy

Purpose: To evaluate the efficacy of the addition of speculoscopy to a Pap smear in cervical cancer screening.

Methods: All women were screened using the Pap smear plus speculoscopy (PapSure) and colposcopy in the multicenter trial. The final diagnosis of each patient was based on a histological evaluation of the colposcopic target biopsy. Results were analyzed using a proportional compare test, sensitivity, specificity and predictive value with significant value determined at less than 0.05.

Results: Of 1,717 eligible cases, 26 cases had LGSIL and 16 cases had HGSIL. Of the Pap smears, five cases had LSIL and 14 cases had HGSIL. Of the combination of the PapSure, 23 cases had LGSIL and 16 cases had HGSIL. The sensitivity of the Pap smear to that of PapSure was calculated at 45.2% and 92.9%, respectively (p < 0.001). The estimated cost to detect a cervical lesion using PapSure is less than that of the Pap smear.

Conclusion: The addition of speculoscopy along with a Pap smear screening results in early detection of cervical lesions in comparison to the Pap smear alone. This screening combination is also more cost-effective and requires fewer visits to the clinic in comparison to a Pap smear screening alone.

Cervical cancer screening; Papanicolaou smear; Speculoscopy

[1] Morrell N.D., Taylor J.R., Snyder R.N., Zeil H.K., Saltz A., Willie S.: "False-negative cytology rates in patients in whom invasive cervical cancer subsequently developed". Obstet. Gynecol., 1982, 60, 41.

[2] Koss L.G., Sherman M.E., Cohen M.B., Anes A.R., Darragh T.M., Lemos L.B. et al.: "Significant reduction in the rate of false-negative cervical smears with neural network-based technology (PapNet Testing System)". Hum. Path., 1997, 28, 1196.

[3] Fahey M.T., Irwig L., Macaskill P.: "Meta-analysis of Pap test accuracy". Am. J. Epidemiol., 1995, 141, 680.

[4] Lonky N.M., Mann W.J., Massad L.S., Mutch D.G., Blanco J.S., Vasilev S.A. et al.: "Ability of visual tests to predict underlying cervical neoplasia: coloscopy and speculoscopy". J. Reprod. Med.,1995, 40, 530.

[5] Cuzick J., Szarewskii A., Terry G., Ho L., Hanby A., Maddox P.: "Human papillomavirus testing in primary cervical screening". Lancet, 1995, 345, 1533.

[6] Loiudice L., Abbiati R., Boselli F., Gecchini G., Costa S., Grossi E. et al.: "Improvement of Pap smear sensitivity using a visual adjunctive procedure: a co-operative Italian study on speculoscopy (GISPE)". Eur. J. Ca. Prev., 1998, 7, 1.

[7] "Season report of Pap smear screening in Taiwan". National Department of Health Taiwan, 1997, 3, 2.

[8] Denny L., Kuhn L., Pollack A., Wainwright H., Wright T.C.: "Evaluation of alternative methods of cervical cancer screening for resource-poor settings". Cancer, 2000, 89, 826.

[9] Benedet J.L., Anderson G.H., Matisic J.P.: "A comprehensive program for cervical cancer detection and management". Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol., 1992, 166, 1254.

[10] Edwards G., Rutkowski C., Palmer C.: "Cervical cancer screening with Papnicolaou smear plus speculoscopy by nurse practitioners in a health maintenance organization". J. Lower. Gen. Tract. Dis., 1997, 1, 141.

[11] Lonky N.M., Sadeghi M., Tsadik G.W., Petitti D.: "The clinical significance of the poor correlation of cervical dysplasia and cervical malignancy with referral cytologic results". Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol., 1999, 181, 560.

[12] Felix J.C., Lonky N.M., Tamura K., Yu K.J., Naidu Y., Lai C.R., et al.: "Aberrant expression of E-cadherin in cervical intraepithelial neoplasia correlates with a false negative papanicolaou smear". Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol., 2002, 186, 1308.

[13] Christoforoni P., Favre A., Cennamo V., Giunta M., Corte G., Grossi C.E.: "Expression of a novel betal integrin in the dysplastic progression of the cervical epithelium". Gynecol. Oneal., 1995, 58, 319.

[14] DeBoer C.J., van Dorst E., van Krieken H., Jansen-van Rhijn C., Wamaar S., Fleuren G.: "Changing roles of cadherins and catenins during progression of squamous intraepithelial lesions in the uterine cervix". Am. J. Pathol., 1999, 155, 505.

[15] Saw H.S., Lee J.K., Lee H.L., Jee H.J., Hyun J.J.: "Natural history of low-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion". J. Lower. Gen. Tract. Dis., 2001, 5, 153.

[16] Kiviat N.K.: "Natural history of cervical neoplasia: overview and update". Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol., 1996, 175, 1099.

[17] Melnikow J., Nuovo J., Willan A.R., Chan B.K.S., Howell L.P.: "Natural history of cervical squamous intraepithelial lesions: a meta-analysis". Obstet. Gynecol., 1998, 92, 727.

[18] Ostor A.G.: "Natural history of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia: a critical review". Int. J. Gynecol. Path., 1993, 12, 186.

[19] Barrow B.A., Richart R.M.: "A statistical model of the natural history of cervical carcinoma. II. Estimates of the transition time from dysplasia to carcinoma in situ". J. Natl. Cancer. Inst., 1970, 45, 1025.