The efficacy of intravenous versus epidural tramadol with patient-controlled analgesia (PCA) in gynecologic cancer pain

We attempted to compare the analgesic effects of tramadol infusion intravenously and epidurally administered through a patient-controlled analgesia (PCA) method for postoperative analgesia following gynaecological cancer surgery. Forty patients undergoing elective cancer surgery, included in the American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) class II and III, were randomly placed into two groups. The patients in the intravenous (IVA) group were administered a 20 mg bolus of tramadol intravenously and the patients in the epideral analgesia (EA) group epidurally five minutes before induction. The PCA equipment was programmed to deliver 20 mg of tramadol as a bolus dose, with a lock-out time of 15 minutes, at a 10 mg/hour infusion rate in both groups. A visual analogue scale (VAS) and patient satisfaction as well as haemodynamic and respiratory parameters were determined at given times postoperatively. Total tramadol consumption at 24 hours and side-effects were recorded. There was no difference between groups based on haemodynamic and respiratory parameters whereas there was a significant difference based on tramadol consumption, VAS and side-effects of tramadol and patient satisfaction between groups. VAS values of patients, 6.85 +/- 1.34 and 3.00 +/- 1.58, respectively, for the IVA group (group 1) and the EA group (group 2) were found to be significantly different. Postoperative patient satisfaction was higher was in group 2 than in group 1 (3.45 and 2.7, respectively). In conclusion, epidural administration of tramadol through the PCA method following gynecologic cancer surgery was found to be a more effective analgesia in lower doses when compared to the intravenous administration.

Postoperative analgesia; Patient-controlled analgesia; Tramadol; Epidural; Intravenous

[1] Hennies H.H., Fridederichs E., Schneider J.: "Receptor binding, analgesic and antitussive potency of tramadol and other selected opioids". Arzneimittelforschung, 1988, 38, 877.

[2] Houmes R.J.M., Voets M.A., Verkaaik A., Erdmann W., Lachmann B.: "Efficacy and safety of tramadol versus morphine for moderate and severe postoperative pain with special regard to respiratory depression". Anesthesia Analg., 1992, 74, 510.

[3] Vickers M.D., O'Flaherty D., Szekely S.M., Read M., Yoshizumi J.: "Tramadol: pain relief by an opioid without depression of respiration". Anaesthesia, 1992, 47, 291.

[4] Lewis K.S., Han N.H.: "Tramadol: a new centrally acting analgesic". Am. J. Health. Syst. Pharm., 1997, 54, 643.

[5] Baraka A., Jabbour S., Ghabash M., Nader A., Khoury G., Sibai A.: "A comparison of epidural tramadol and epidural morphine for postoperative analgesia". Can. J. Anaesth., 1993, 40, 308.

[6] Lee C.R., McTavish D., Sorkin E.M.: "Tramadol. A preliminary review of its pharmacodynamic and pharmacokinetic properties, and therapeutic potential in acute and chronic pain states". Drugs, 1993, 46, 313.

[7] Codd E.E., Shank R.P., Raffa R.B., Vaught J.L.: "Opioid binding potency and inhibition or neurotransmitter uptake by the analgesic tramadol" (abstract). Meeting of the Society for Neuroscience. St. Louis, MO, USA, 1990.

[8] Driessen B., Reimann W.: "Effects of tramadol on noradrenaline release from rat brain cortex slices". Naunyn-Schmiedeberg's Archives Pharmacol., 1989, 339, R89.

[9] Hennies H.H., Friderichs E., Wilsmann K., Flohe L.: "Effect of the opioid analgesic tramadol on inactivation of norepinephrine and serotonin". Biochem. Pharmacol., 1982, 31, 1654.

[10] Striebel H.W., Hackenberger J.: "Comparison of tramadol/metamizole infusion versus combined tramadol infusion and ibuprofen suppositories for postoperative pain management after hysterectomy". Anaesthetist, 1992, 41, 354.

[11] Lehmann K.A., Brand-Stavroulaki A., Rworzak H.: "The influence of demand and loading dose on the efficacy of postoperative patient-controlled analgesia with tramadol". Pain, 1986, 4, 146.

[12] Hackl W., Fitzal S., Lackner F., Weindlmayr-Goettel M.: "Vergleich von Fentanyl und Tramadol zur Schmerzbehandlung mittels On-Demand-Analgasie-Computer in der friihen postoperativen Phase". Anaesthetist, 1986, 35, 665.

[13] Dick W., Knoche E., Grundlanch G., Klein I.: "Klinish experimentelle Untersuchungen zur postoperativen Infusionsanalgesie". Anaesthesist., 1983, 32, 272.

[14] Lehmann K.A., Gordes B.: "Postoperative On-demand Analgesie mit Buprenorphin". Anaesthetist, 1988, 37, 65.

[15] Bailey P.L., Rhondeau S., Schafer P.G., Lu J.K. et al.: "Dose response pharmacology of intrathecal morphine in human volunteers". Anesthesiology, 1993, 79, 49.

[16] Morgan M.: "The rational use of intrathecal and extradural opioids". Br. J. Anaesth., 1989, 63, 165.

[17] Vincent R.D., Chestnut D.H., Choi W.W., Ostman P.L., Bates J.N.: "Does epidural fentanyl decrease the efficacy of epidural morphine after caesarean delivery?". Anesth. Analg., 1992, 74, 658.

[18] Delilkan A.E., Vijayan R.: "Epidural tramadol for postoperative pain relief'. Anaesthesia, 1993, 48, 328.